Pie irons are a classic tool for making delicious stuffed sandwiches over a campfire or grill. The best models combine durable cast iron construction with user-friendly features, but they vary in size, versatility, and price. The Campfire Pie Iron 4.9″ Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker stands out as the overall top pick for its size and build quality, while the Uno Casa XL Pie Irons offer great value with included recipes. However, choosing the right pie iron involves tradeoffs between weight, ease of cleaning, and price. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown of the best options and what to consider before buying.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The largest pie irons tend to be more versatile but also heavier and less portable.
- Pre-seasoned cast iron models often require less maintenance but need proper care to avoid rust.
- Set options with multiple pieces provide better value but can be bulkier to store.
- The best pie irons balance durability with ease of handling, especially for beginner users.
- Price varies widely, with premium models offering more features but not always necessary for casual use.
| Campfire Pie Iron 4.9″ Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, 2 Pieces with Storage Bag |  | Best Overall for Versatility and Size | Material: Cast iron | Size: 4.9 inches | Handles: 22.6 inches wooden handles | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Double Pie Irons for Camping Cast Iron, Portable Mountain Campfire Pie Maker, Cast Iron Campfire Pudgy Maker, Sandwich Press for Camping |  | Best for Large Portions and Versatility | Size: 4.33″x8.26″ | Material: Cast Iron | Handle: Removable Stainless Steel | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Uno Casa XL Pie Irons Cast Iron Sandwich Maker with Recipe Book |  | Best for Easy Handling and Multi-Use Camping Meals | Material: Cast iron | Size: XL | Handles: Removable, 13.8″ & 21.6″ | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Mountain Pie Maker Cast Iron, Campfire Pie Iron, Hobo Pie Maker for Camping, 2-Pack |  | Best for Durability and Outdoor Versatility | Material: Cast Iron | Handles: Wooden | Set Includes: 2 Pie Irons | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, Cast Iron Campfire Pie Cooker |  | Best for Spacious Cooking and Dual Surfaces | Material: Cast Iron, Alloy Steel, Wood | Finish Type: Non-Stick | Item Dimensions: 26 x 8 x 1.6 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Campfire Pie Iron 4.9″ Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, 4 Pcs with Storage Bag |  | Best for Large Campfire Meals and Family Camping | Size: 4.9 inches | Handles: 22.6 inches thickened handles | Material: Cast iron | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Double Cast Iron Pie Iron for Camping, Pre-seasoned Sandwich Maker and Campfire Cooker |  | Best for Versatile Outdoor Cooking and Family Meals | Material: Cast iron | Size: 4.33″ x 8.46″ | Handles: Removable stainless steel with S-hook | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| AILITOR Cast Iron Pie Maker Set of 2 for Camping with Storage Bag |  | Best for Budget-Friendly, Compact Camping Sets | Material: Cast iron | Number of pieces: 2 | Includes: Storage bag | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Uno Casa Pie Iron Sandwich Maker with Recipe Book |  | Best for Creativity and Meal Inspiration on Outdoor Adventures | Material: Cast iron | Handle Lengths: 13.8 inches and 21.6 inches | Features: Non-stick, rust-proof, pre-seasoned, removable handles, secure hook | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Coghlan’s Cast Iron Double Camp Cooker – Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich Maker with Removable Handles |  | Best for Dual Cooking and Efficiency in Outdoor Settings | Cooking Surface: Double | Material: Cast iron | Pre-seasoned: Yes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| pie iron | Material | Handles | Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| Campfire Pie Iron 4.9" Large C | Cast iron | 22.6 inches wooden handles | 4.9 inches |
| Double Pie Irons for Camping C | Cast Iron | — | 4.33"x8.26" |
| Uno Casa XL Pie Irons Cast Iro | Cast iron | Removable, 13.8" & 21.6" | XL |
| Mountain Pie Maker Cast Iron | Cast Iron | Wooden | — |
| Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker | Cast Iron, Alloy Steel, Wood | — | — |
| Campfire Pie Iron 4.9" Large C | Cast iron | 22.6 inches thickened handles | 4.9 inches |
| Double Cast Iron Pie Iron for | Cast iron | Removable stainless steel with S-hook | 4.33" x 8.46" |
| AILITOR Cast Iron Pie Maker Se | Cast iron | — | — |
| Uno Casa Pie Iron Sandwich Mak | Cast iron | — | — |
| Coghlan’s Cast Iron Double Cam | Cast iron | Removable, stay-cool wooden | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Campfire Pie Iron 4.9″ Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, 2 Pieces with Storage Bag
This large cast iron pie iron excels in offering a spacious cooking surface, making it ideal for hearty campfire meals. Compared to smaller options like the Uno Casa XL, its larger footprint allows for bigger sandwiches and more filling options. The long wooden handles provide safety during outdoor use, though the cast iron’s weight may be a concern for those seeking lightweight gear. It requires proper seasoning to achieve non-stick performance, which can be an extra step for casual users. The included storage bag enhances portability, making it a solid choice for serious campers who prioritize capacity and durability over weight.
Pros:- Large cooking space for hearty meals
- Long heatproof handles for safe outdoor use
- Includes a convenient storage bag for transport
Cons:- Heavy due to cast iron construction
- Requires thorough seasoning to prevent sticking
- Bulky for limited storage space
Best for: Campers and outdoor enthusiasts who need a durable, large-capacity pie iron for family-sized meals
Not ideal for: Hikers or backpackers seeking lightweight, compact cookware for quick, solo meals
- Material:Cast iron
- Size:4.9 inches
- Handles:22.6 inches wooden handles
- Number of Pieces:2
- Includes:Storage bag
Our verdict“This pie iron is best suited for dedicated campers who value size and durability over portability.”
Double Pie Irons for Camping Cast Iron, Portable Mountain Campfire Pie Maker, Cast Iron Campfire Pudgy Maker, Sandwich Press for Camping
Compared with the single larger options like the Campfire Pie Iron, this double cast iron model offers the advantage of cooking two meals simultaneously or creating larger, double-layer sandwiches. Its open design simplifies cleaning, while the removable stainless steel handles add portability. However, its notable weight and need for seasoning make it less ideal for those who prioritize lightweight gear or quick setup. Its compatibility with multiple heat sources, including campfires and stoves, positions it as a versatile choice for outdoor cooking enthusiasts who want flexibility and efficiency in meal prep, especially for groups or families.
Pros:- Large size suitable for bigger food portions
- Excellent heat distribution thanks to cast iron
- Portable and easy to disassemble for cleaning
Cons:- Heavy weight may hinder portability
- Requires regular seasoning to prevent rust
- Handle can get hot during use
Best for: Campers, tailgaters, or outdoor cooks who want a versatile, large-capacity pie iron for multiple servings
Not ideal for: Backpackers or solo hikers needing ultra-light, compact cookware due to its weight and size
- Size:4.33″x8.26″
- Material:Cast Iron
- Handle:Removable Stainless Steel
- Design:Double square pie iron head, open design
- Compatibility:Gas stoves, induction, campfires
Our verdict“This double pie iron is ideal for outdoor cooks who prioritize capacity and versatility over ultra-lightweight design.”
Uno Casa XL Pie Irons Cast Iron Sandwich Maker with Recipe Book
The Uno Casa XL pie iron combines a large, durable cast iron build with removable handles, making it easy to clean and handle. Its non-stick, rust-proof surface enhances cooking performance, especially compared to older, seasoned-only designs like the Mountain Pie Maker. However, its weight and need for regular seasoning to prevent rust mean it isn’t the best choice for those seeking ultra-light, low-maintenance options. The included recipe book offers inspiration for a variety of meals, making it a versatile pick for campers who enjoy experimenting with different recipes without sacrificing durability.
Pros:- Large size suitable for multiple servings
- Removable handles for easy cleaning
- Non-stick, rust-proof surface for easy maintenance
Cons:- Heavy compared to lighter camping cookware
- Requires proper seasoning to prevent rust
- Limited to high-heat or campfire cooking
Best for: Camping families or casual outdoor cooks who want a durable, multi-use pie iron with easy cleaning
Not ideal for: Backpackers or minimalist campers who need lightweight, compact cookware for quick meals
- Material:Cast iron
- Size:XL
- Handles:Removable, 13.8″ & 21.6″
- Features:Non-stick, rust-proof, includes recipe book
Our verdict“This pick makes the most sense for outdoor cooks who value ease of use and multi-functionality over weight savings.”
Mountain Pie Maker Cast Iron, Campfire Pie Iron, Hobo Pie Maker for Camping, 2-Pack
This 2-pack set offers pre-seasoned cast iron pie irons ideal for outdoor use, with durable handles and versatile design. The pre-seasoned surface reduces initial cleanup effort compared to unseasoned cast iron like the Campfire Pie Iron, but it still requires ongoing maintenance to prevent rust. The wooden handles provide good safety, but they may become hot during use. Compared to single-piece models, this set is perfect for outdoor gatherings or camping groups wanting multiple cooking options or larger meals. Its heavy-duty construction guarantees even heat distribution for consistent results, but the weight and maintenance needs mean it’s best for dedicated outdoor cooks.
Pros:- Durable heavy-duty cast iron construction
- Pre-seasoned for nonstick cooking
- Includes 2 pie irons for versatile use
Cons:- Requires maintenance to prevent rust
- Handles can get hot during use
- Heavy for casual backpackers
Best for: Outdoor enthusiasts or groups who want multiple pie irons for campfire cooking and outdoor gatherings
Not ideal for: Travelers seeking lightweight, easy-to-pack cookware for short trips or solo camping
- Material:Cast Iron
- Handles:Wooden
- Set Includes:2 Pie Irons
- Pre-seasoned:Yes
Our verdict“This set is perfect for outdoor groups that need durable, reliable pie irons with multiple options for campfire cooking.”
Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, Cast Iron Campfire Pie Cooker
Compared with smaller, single-surface options like the Uno Casa XL, this double cast iron pie iron offers a large 8 x 4.4-inch cooking area with dual flat and grill surfaces, making it suitable for a variety of meals. Its robust, pre-seasoned cast iron ensures even heat distribution, and the long wooden handle adds safety. However, its size and weight make it less suitable for backpackers or solo campers. Cleaning requires hands-on effort, and it’s not dishwasher safe. This model is best for outdoor cooks who want to prepare larger meals or sandwiches with different cooking styles in one device, especially during extended camping trips or outdoor gatherings.
Pros:- Large, spacious cooking surface
- Dual cooking options (flat and grill)
- Pre-seasoned cast iron for even heating
Cons:- Heavy and bulky for portability
- Requires careful hand washing
- Not dishwasher safe
Best for: Group campers or outdoor cooks needing a large, versatile pie iron for multiple meal styles
Not ideal for: Solo backpackers or those with limited storage space due to its size and weight
- Material:Cast Iron, Alloy Steel, Wood
- Finish Type:Non-Stick
- Item Dimensions:26 x 8 x 1.6 inches
- Item Weight:4.6 Pounds
- Shape:Rectangular
- Handle Length:20.4 inches
Our verdict“This double pie iron is best for outdoor cooks focused on preparing larger, multi-style meals in a single device, despite its weight.”
Campfire Pie Iron 4.9″ Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker for Camping, 4 Pcs with Storage Bag
This pie iron stands out for its generous 4.9-inch cooking surface, making it ideal for hearty family meals around the campfire. Compared with the Double Pie Irons for Camping, it offers more cooking capacity per piece, though it sacrifices some versatility for larger portions. Its cast iron build ensures even heat distribution, but it adds significant weight and requires maintenance to prevent rust. The long handles provide safety during flipping, yet can feel cumbersome for smaller hands or quick adjustments. The inclusion of a storage bag boosts portability, making it a solid choice for dedicated outdoor cooks who prioritize substantial servings. However, the heaviness and need for regular seasoning may deter casual users who prefer lightweight, low-maintenance options.
Pros:- Large 4.9-inch cooking surface perfect for hearty meals
- Long heatproof handles for safe flipping and handling
- Includes a storage bag for easy transport
- Naturally seasoned cast iron prevents sticking
Cons:- Heavy weight can be cumbersome to carry or maneuver
- Requires regular seasoning and maintenance to prevent rust
- Long handles may be awkward for smaller users
Best for: Families or groups who need to cook large, filling meals during camping trips and value durability.
Not ideal for: Hikers or backpackers seeking lightweight gear due to its heavy cast iron construction and long handles.
- Size:4.9 inches
- Handles:22.6 inches thickened handles
- Material:Cast iron
- Number of pieces:4
- Includes:Storage bag
- Handle length:21.7 inches
Our verdict“This pick suits outdoor enthusiasts who prioritize capacity and durability over portability and ease of maintenance.”
Double Cast Iron Pie Iron for Camping, Pre-seasoned Sandwich Maker and Campfire Cooker
This heavy-duty cast iron pie iron excels in versatility, with a large 4.33″ x 8.46″ surface that can handle multiple sandwiches or pies at once. Unlike the Campfire Pie Iron 4.9″ Large, it offers a double-sided cooking surface, making it more efficient for feeding groups but at the cost of increased weight and bulk. Its pre-seasoned finish ensures immediate use, and the removable stainless steel handles improve safety and cleaning. It’s compatible with campfires, ovens, and grills, adding flexibility for outdoor and indoor use. However, it demands proper seasoning to prevent rust and can be cumbersome to transport due to its weight. Handles become hot during use, so careful handling is necessary, especially for casual campers or those with limited strength.
Pros:- Double cooking surface saves time and increases output
- Pre-seasoned for ready-to-use performance
- Removable handles for easier cleaning and safety
- Suitable for campfire, oven, and grill cooking
Cons:- Heavier and bulkier than single-iron options
- Handles can become hot during use
- Requires careful seasoning and maintenance
Best for: Outdoor families or groups who want to cook multiple items simultaneously and value multi-method use.
Not ideal for: Solo campers or backpackers seeking lightweight, compact tools because of its heavier cast iron design.
- Material:Cast iron
- Size:4.33″ x 8.46″
- Handles:Removable stainless steel with S-hook
- Pre-seasoned:Yes
- Suitable for:Campfire, oven, stove, grill
Our verdict“This model appeals to outdoor cooks who need to prepare multiple meals efficiently and don’t mind extra weight and care routines.”
AILITOR Cast Iron Pie Maker Set of 2 for Camping with Storage Bag
The AILITOR set offers two pre-seasoned cast iron pie makers, making it a practical choice for outdoor enthusiasts who want to share the experience with a partner or family. Compared with the larger, more elaborate options like the Campfire Pie Iron 4.9″ Large, these irons are more manageable in size, though they still provide a solid cast iron foundation for even heating. The long wooden handles ensure safe handling over campfires, but they require care to avoid damage or rust. This set is ideal for casual campers or backyard cooks who want a durable, straightforward option without the bulk of larger models. Its weight and care requirements may discourage those seeking quick, low-maintenance gear.
Pros:- Includes two cast iron pie makers for versatility and sharing
- Durable cast iron construction for even heating
- Long wooden handles for safe handling
- Pre-seasoned surface for easy use
Cons:- Heavy weight and bulk may be cumbersome for backpacking
- Requires proper care to prevent rust and maintain seasoning
- Handles may need careful handling to avoid damage
Best for: Casual campers or backyard grillers seeking a simple, durable set with multiple irons for sharing the fun.
Not ideal for: Hikers or minimalist campers who prefer ultra-lightweight, compact gear with minimal upkeep.
- Material:Cast iron
- Number of pieces:2
- Includes:Storage bag
- Handle type:Wooden
- Pre-seasoned:Yes
Our verdict“This set is perfect for casual outdoor cooks who want a reliable, shared pie-making experience without worrying about high-tech features.”
Uno Casa Pie Iron Sandwich Maker with Recipe Book
The Uno Casa Pie Iron combines durability with versatility, featuring a large, multi-use design that includes a flavor-enhancing grill grid. Compared with the Coghlan’s Double Camp Cooker, it offers a more comprehensive set of features, including a recipe book to inspire new meal ideas. The removable handles make cleaning and transport easier, while the rust-proof, pre-seasoned cast iron ensures longevity. Its size and multi-function capability make it suitable for a variety of outdoor cooking adventures, but the handles can feel heavy, and proper care is vital to prevent rust. This pick appeals to cooks who value creative meals and want a reliable, multi-purpose tool for outdoor use.
Pros:- Large, multi-use design for various meals
- Removable handles for easy cleaning and storage
- Rust-proof, pre-seasoned cast iron for durability
- Includes recipe book for meal ideas
Cons:- Handles may be heavy for some users
- Requires diligent drying and maintenance to prevent rust
- Not dishwasher safe, needs hand cleaning
Best for: Outdoor cooks who enjoy experimenting with different recipes and need a durable, multi-use iron.
Not ideal for: Casual campers seeking lightweight, simple tools with minimal upkeep, as this model emphasizes versatility over portability.
- Material:Cast iron
- Handle Lengths:13.8 inches and 21.6 inches
- Features:Non-stick, rust-proof, pre-seasoned, removable handles, secure hook
Our verdict“This option is best for outdoor chefs who prioritize creative cooking and durability over minimal weight or quick setup.”
Coghlan’s Cast Iron Double Camp Cooker – Pre-Seasoned Pie Iron Sandwich Maker with Removable Handles
The Coghlan’s double camp cooker stands out for its ability to cook two sandwiches or pies at once, making it highly efficient for groups or busy outdoor cooks. Its pre-seasoned cast iron guarantees even heating right out of the box, unlike some budget options that require extensive seasoning. The break-apart hinge allows for thorough cleaning, and stay-cool wooden handles promote safety. Compared with the Double Cast Iron Pie Iron, it emphasizes safety and cleaning ease, though it shares the same weight and seasoning upkeep. Handles may loosen over time, and it’s heavier than single-iron models, limiting portability for solo adventures.
Pros:- Cook two items at once for efficiency
- Pre-seasoned for immediate use
- Removable, stay-cool wooden handles
- Break-apart hinge simplifies cleaning
Cons:- Handles may become loose over time
- Heavy weight may limit portability
- Requires maintenance to preserve seasoning
Best for: Campers or outdoor cooks who need to prepare multiple items simultaneously and prioritize safety and cleaning convenience.
Not ideal for: Lightweight backpackers or solo campers who prefer compact, low-maintenance gear due to its weight and size.
- Cooking Surface:Double
- Material:Cast iron
- Pre-seasoned:Yes
- Handles:Removable, stay-cool wooden
- Hinge:Break-apart
Our verdict“This model suits outdoor cooks who want to maximize efficiency and safety, accepting the tradeoff of extra weight and upkeep.”
How We Picked
I evaluated each pie iron based on durability, ease of use, size, maintenance, and value. Cast iron construction was a key factor, as it ensures even heating and longevity. I also considered user-friendly features like handles, weight, and included accessories. Products that offered a good balance of quality and affordability ranked higher, while those with major drawbacks or limited versatility fell lower. This ranking reflects what real users need from a reliable pie iron for camping, grilling, or backyard use.| pie iron | Material |
|---|---|
| Campfire Pie Iron 4.9" Large C | Cast iron |
| Double Pie Irons for Camping C | Cast Iron |
| Uno Casa XL Pie Irons Cast Iro | Cast iron |
| Mountain Pie Maker Cast Iron | Cast Iron |
| Double Pie Iron Sandwich Maker | Cast Iron, Alloy Steel, Wood |
| Campfire Pie Iron 4.9" Large C | Cast iron |
| Double Cast Iron Pie Iron for | Cast iron |
| AILITOR Cast Iron Pie Maker Se | Cast iron |
| Uno Casa Pie Iron Sandwich Mak | Cast iron |
| Coghlan’s Cast Iron Double Cam | Cast iron |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Pie Irons
Choosing the right pie iron depends on several factors that impact your cooking experience and convenience. Beyond just price, consider how the size, material, and features align with your typical use case. A well-chosen pie iron can last for years, but the wrong one might be cumbersome or prone to rust. Here are key factors to keep in mind:Size and Capacity
Size impacts how much food you can prepare at once and how portable the pie iron is. Larger models are better for feeding groups or making bigger sandwiches, but they tend to be heavier and bulkier for camping trips. Smaller irons are lightweight and easier to handle but may limit portion sizes. Consider your typical cooking needs and storage space when choosing the size.
Material and Durability
Cast iron is the most common and durable material, providing excellent heat retention and even cooking. Pre-seasoned cast iron offers good longevity but requires proper care to avoid rust. Some models incorporate stainless steel or other coatings for easier maintenance, though they might compromise heat distribution. Think about how much effort you’re willing to invest in upkeep versus convenience.
Ease of Use and Handling
Look for models with sturdy handles that stay cool and provide a comfortable grip. Non-slip or insulated handles can improve safety, especially when handling hot cookware. The weight of the pie iron affects maneuverability; heavier models feel more substantial but can be tiring over time. Check if the design allows for easy flipping and cleaning.
Cleaning and Maintenance
Some pie irons are dishwasher safe, but most require hand washing and drying to prevent rust. Seasoned cast iron needs periodic re-seasoning, which can be a drawback for some users. Non-stick coatings or enamel finishes reduce cleaning effort but might wear over time. Consider how much maintenance you’re willing to do to keep your pie iron in top shape.
Price and Value
Prices range from budget-friendly options to high-end models with extra features. Cheaper irons often lack durability or proper seasoning, leading to potential rust or uneven cooking. Higher-priced options tend to offer better construction, longevity, and accessories like recipe books or storage bags. Balance your budget with your expected frequency of use and desired longevity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a pie iron on a regular grill or stove?
Yes, most cast iron pie irons can be used on a standard grill or over a campfire. They are designed to withstand high heat and are versatile enough for various cooking methods. However, ensure the handles are heat-resistant and that the iron heats evenly to prevent burning or sticking. Using a lower heat setting can help achieve better results without scorching your food.
How do I prevent rust on my cast iron pie iron?
Preventing rust involves proper cleaning, drying, and seasoning. After each use, wash the pie iron with hot water and dry it thoroughly—never air dry or leave it wet. Apply a thin layer of cooking oil before storing to maintain the seasoning and create a protective barrier. Regularly re-season the iron by applying oil and heating it until it smokes slightly, especially if you notice rust spots or dullness.
Are set of multiple pie irons worth the extra cost?
Sets with multiple pie irons often provide better value, especially if you plan to cook for a family or entertain guests. They allow you to prepare different fillings simultaneously or have backups ready for frequent use. However, they can be bulkier to store and may increase the initial investment. Consider your storage space and cooking frequency before opting for a set.
What size should I choose for camping trips?
For camping, lightweight and compact models tend to be the best choice, even if they have smaller cooking surfaces. A smaller size reduces weight and makes handling easier over open flames. However, if you’re cooking for a group, a larger model might be worth the extra weight for its increased capacity. Balance size with portability based on your typical camping setup.
How do I clean a pie iron after use?
Cleaning a cast iron pie iron involves wiping off excess food with a cloth or brush while still warm, then rinsing with hot water if necessary. Avoid using soap, which can strip the seasoning. For stubborn residues, a scraper or coarse salt can help. Dry it thoroughly immediately after washing, then apply a light coat of oil before storing to prevent rust.
Conclusion
For most users, the Campfire Pie Iron 4.9″ Large Cast Iron Sandwich Maker offers a winning combination of size, durability, and ease of use, making it the best overall pick. Budget-conscious buyers will appreciate the Uno Casa XL Pie Irons for their value and included recipe book, while those seeking premium quality might prefer the Coghlan’s Cast Iron Double Camp Cooker for its robust build. Beginners should focus on models with comfortable handles and simple maintenance, whereas experienced campers may opt for larger, multi-piece sets for versatility. Ultimately, your choice depends on your specific needs, cooking style, and willingness to care for your equipment.
